Ape Escape: Please Rate

[crait]

1 >

2 >

3 >

Didn't follow any tutorials for this one.
I wanted to get a good feel of depth and work on another style than I usually do. Please rate and tell me which is best! I'm really wanting some criticism on these! Thanks!

The top image seems to have more detail but is darker.

The middle image looks good but has less detail.

The bottom pic is washed out. It's no good.

[crait]

Okay, played with the levels, contrast, saturation....
One >
New >
Two >

How come I can't see the light shining on the helmet on the bottom too like I can on the top one?

Keep the top one. It isn't as bright but has more detail and that is always a good thing.

[crait]

Because I made the overall color of the helmet color closer to white. The glare's color and the helmet color are soo close, you can't see the difference with your naked eye.

The blur effect really doesn't go with the entire image.
Your smudge looks good though. Lighting could use a bit of work.
Also try using a different font.

I'm giving it 7/10

[crait]

Thanks Que and Mailas for the criticism.

I will C&C later. Glad you liked the render I found for you good enough

I don't know.

I liked the third one.

id say on the new post.... top ones the best.

id say on the new post.... top ones the best.

I agree! and ape escape was a pretty good game!